Mouthpiece Work / Vintage Mouthpieces - curve increments reading
FROM: genoasax (genoasax)
SUBJECT: Vintage Mouthpieces - curve increments reading
Hello, I'm Italian. I play Tenor Saxophone. I'm very interested in Mouthpiece Refacing. I read the E.D.Brand Manual and I own a good (I hope) Refacing Kit; I need only a Taper Gauge to mesaure the Tip Opening. I would like to make duplicates of some old Saxhophone's Mouthpieces (Meyer - Brilhart - Berg Larsen - Link - etc..) On the Internet I can only find information about the tip opening, but not about their Facing Length and their Curve Increments Reading. I would be happy to receive information about that, but not about all Vintage Mouthpieces, maybe about some of those, so that I could try to begin. I would be grateful if you could help me! Thank you so much. Best Wishes, Giuseppe Formisano.
FROM: jimreed_45409 (jimreed_45409)
SUBJECT: Re: Vintage Mouthpieces - curve increments reading
Hi Giuseppe, There are a lot of people who know much more about working with mouthpieces than myself so I can't offer much information other than about current taper gauges. The old fashioned, long ones, pictured in the Brand manual, among other places, have been replaced by two smaller ones, with red handles. One taper gauge measures .035-.080 and the other measures .080-.125. These can be purchased as a red handle tip gauge set for $US 30 plus shipping. The major advantage is these gauges are readily available from J.J. Babbitt and are what they currently use for their own mouthpiece work. I suspect the Winslow gauge is much more precise but I'm still waiting for the one I have backordered from the Woodwind & Brasswind. Contact Jim Green, at J.J. Babbitt, for more information about obtaining a set of tape gauges. J.J. Babbitt Co. Inc. P.O. Box 1264 Elkhart, IN 46516 574-293-0805 574-293-6514 Best wishes with this, Jim
FROM: kwbradbury (kwbradbury)
SUBJECT: Re: Vintage Mouthpieces - curve increments reading
Ralph Morgan published some lay schedules in Sax Journal V17, #5 (March/April 1993). Included are some numbers for Bb clarinet, Alto, Tenor, Bari Sax and Bass clarinet. Mostly close facings, since they are from the 1950s. Makes: Woodwind, Kaspar, Selmer, Rico, Kay- O'Brien, Bundy, Otto Link, Goldbeck, Dick Stabile, Gregory. A few web sites have facing lengths, but no intermediate points. I've seen Selmer, Yamaha, Vandoren, and Lawton. Check the Bookmarks on our MP Work site. Be aware that some makers define facing length as the distance to a 0.0015" feeler and some seem to give the distance to where the flat table starts (like using a 0.0000" feeler). I think Vandoren gives the longer length. The best way to try to duplicate a mouthpiece is to have one as a model. You can measure it yourself and play test your version against it. I have a notebook of pieces I have measured using my system of feelers, which are not "standard" as I have reported in earlier posts. They can be converted to other feeler gage increments using a curve fit spreadsheet like the one I posted in the Files area. If there is a particular one you are interested in, I can post my readings if I have it. But this would not be a "spec" just my readings. They would contain manufacturing variation and any errors I might have made. That is why I like to curve fit my readings to smooth out the bumps. I think most of the time these bumps are errors in manufacturing and measurement, not features. If you get the opportunity to measure several mouthpieces from the same maker marked the same, you will get a good feel for this variation. Jon Van Wie once posted his spec for a Link 7 Tenor (.100" tip): .0015/48, .010/38, .024/28, .034/22, .050/16. From a curve fit, I think .034/23 would be a smoother curve, but you can be the judge. JVW's Meyer 5 Alto (.073" tip) was: .0015/40, .010/30, .024/20, .034/15, .050/8
FROM: tenorman1952 (Paul Coats)
SUBJECT: Re: Vintage Mouthpieces - curve increments reading
Giuseppe: In your version of the EDBrand manual, in the back of the mouthpiece chapter, do you have the facing schedules of various old mouthpieces? Perhaps that is just in the mouthpiece book? Paul genoasax wrote: > Hello, > I'm Italian. I play Tenor Saxophone. > I'm very interested in Mouthpiece Refacing. > I read the E.D.Brand Manual and I own a good (I hope) Refacing Kit; > I need only a Taper Gauge to mesaure the Tip Opening. > I would like to make duplicates of some old Saxhophone's Mouthpieces > (Meyer - Brilhart - Berg Larsen - Link - etc..) On the Internet I can > only find information about the tip opening, but not about their > Facing Length and their Curve Increments Reading. > I would be happy to receive information about that, but not about all > Vintage Mouthpieces, maybe about some of those, so that I could try > to begin. > I would be grateful if you could help me! > Thank you so much. Best Wishes, Giuseppe Formisano. > > > Yahoo! Groups Sponsor ADVERTISEMENT [Image] > > Got a Mouthpiece Work question? Send it to > MouthpieceWork@yahoogroups.com > > Visit the site at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/MouthpieceWork to see > the Files, Photos and Bookmarks relating to Mouthpiece Work. > > To see and modify your groups, go to http://groups.yahoo.com/mygroups > > Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service. -- Link to Paul's articles from Home page of "Sax on the Web": http://www.saxontheweb.net or directly to Paul's articles at: http://www.saxontheweb.net/Coats/ Listen to Paul's MP3's at: http://briefcase.yahoo.com/tenorman1952 and view photos.
FROM: tenorman1952 (Paul Coats)
SUBJECT: Re: Vintage Mouthpieces - curve increments reading
Keith: I have these, separately from an old Eric Brand book, and also from the Sax Journal article. I believe they are the same facing schedules. It standard way to measure and specify facing length has always been with the use of the .0015� feeler. kwbradbury wrote: > Ralph Morgan published some lay schedules in Sax Journal V17, #5 > (March/April 1993). Included are some numbers for Bb clarinet, > Alto, Tenor, Bari Sax and Bass clarinet. Mostly close facings, since > they are from the 1950s. Makes: Woodwind, Kaspar, Selmer, Rico, Kay- > O'Brien, Bundy, Otto Link, Goldbeck, Dick Stabile, Gregory. > > A few web sites have facing lengths, but no intermediate points. > I've seen Selmer, Yamaha, Vandoren, and Lawton. Check the Bookmarks > on our MP Work site. Be aware that some makers define facing length > as the distance to a 0.0015" feeler and some seem to give the > distance to where the flat table starts (like using a 0.0000" > feeler). I think Vandoren gives the longer length. > > The best way to try to duplicate a mouthpiece is to have one as a > model. You can measure it yourself and play test your version > against it. > > I have a notebook of pieces I have measured using my system of > feelers, which are not "standard" as I have reported in earlier > posts. They can be converted to other feeler gage increments using a > curve fit spreadsheet like the one I posted in the Files area. If > there is a particular one you are interested in, I can post my > readings if I have it. But this would not be a "spec" just my > readings. They would contain manufacturing variation and any errors > I might have made. That is why I like to curve fit my readings to > smooth out the bumps. I think most of the time these bumps are > errors in manufacturing and measurement, not features. If you get > the opportunity to measure several mouthpieces from the same maker > marked the same, you will get a good feel for this variation. > > Jon Van Wie once posted his spec for a Link 7 Tenor (.100" tip): > .0015/48, .010/38, .024/28, .034/22, .050/16. From a curve fit, I > think .034/23 would be a smoother curve, but you can be the judge. > > JVW's Meyer 5 Alto (.073" tip) was: > .0015/40, .010/30, .024/20, .034/15, .050/8 > > > > Yahoo! Groups Sponsor ADVERTISEMENT [Image] > > Got a Mouthpiece Work question? Send it to > MouthpieceWork@yahoogroups.com > > Visit the site at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/MouthpieceWork to see > the Files, Photos and Bookmarks relating to Mouthpiece Work. > > To see and modify your groups, go to http://groups.yahoo.com/mygroups > > Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service. -- Link to Paul's articles from Home page of "Sax on the Web": http://www.saxontheweb.net or directly to Paul's articles at: http://www.saxontheweb.net/Coats/ Listen to Paul's MP3's at: http://briefcase.yahoo.com/tenorman1952 and view photos.
FROM: kwbradbury (kwbradbury)
SUBJECT: Re: Vintage Mouthpieces - curve increments reading
Seems like a lot of the figures and tables in Ralph's SJ columns were from the E.Brand book.